Forum Super Search
Posting Date From:
Posting Date To:
Train Type:
ONLY with Pic/Vid:
Sort by: Date:     Word Count:     Popularity:     
Public:    Pvt: Monitor:    RailFan Club:    

Full Site Search
Fri Jan 20, 2017 17:44:27 ISTHomeTrainsΣChainsAtlasPNRForumGalleryNewsFAQTripsLoginFeedback
Fri Jan 20, 2017 17:44:27 IST

Blog Entry# 1939889  
Posted: Jul 24 2016 (08:47)

3 Responses
Last Response: Jul 24 2016 (21:42)
Rail News
New Facilities/TechnologyML/Mumbai Local  -  
Jul 24 2016 (08:25)   Money problems stall plan to expand local train network

For Better Managed Indian Railways~   945 news posts
Entry# 1939889   News Entry# 274655         Tags   Past Edits
An expansion plan for Mumbai’s suburban rail network is stuck with the railway ministry as it is unsure whether the plan is financial sustainable in the long-term, given the huge losses that both the Central and Western Railway incur every year. The expansion, if carried out, would increase capacity, improve connectivity and reduce travel time for lakhs for commuters.
The plan is part of the Mumbai Urban Transport Project (MUTP) 3 and includes three key projects sanctioned by the railway ministry in 2015-16 – an elevated track from Airoli to Kalwa, doubling the number of lines between Panvel and Karjat, and adding a third and fourth line between Virar and Dahanu.
projects were sent to NITI Ayog (which has replaced the Planning Commission of India) for approval, which raised questions about its long-term financial sustainability and asked the railways to include a communication-based travel control (CBTC) system in MUTP 3, which would speed up train operations. “NITI Ayog gave in-principal approval to the project in February, subject to the condition that CBTC is included in MUTP 3 and we submit a financial sustainability plan for the new lines. However, to date, the railways has not replied to it,” said senior railway official, who did not wish to be named as he is not authorised to speak to the media.
The railway ministry is still not sure whether the new projects are financial sustainable. The Central and Western Railway (WR) incur a combined loss of about Rs 1,500 crore a year on operating and maintaining the city’s suburban train network as the revenue they earn from ticket sales is far less than the cost of running local train services. Railway officials are concerned that if the networks or services are expanded, their losses will increase further.
The senior railway official added, “The only way of expanding railway services is to increase fares and make the train network financially sustainable. We cannot compare train services in Mumbai to those in other cities; its fare structure should be delinked from others.”
The railways’ most recent attempt to hike suburban train fares came soon after Narendra Modi government assumed power in 2014. In his first railway budget, then railways minister Sadanan Gowda proposed increasing fares but this was cancelled after commuters reacted angrily.
Transport experts said the issue should be treated as one of urban governance as the expansion would ease congestion in Mumbai. They agreed, however, that fares will have to be increased gradually to make the suburban network financially sustainable. It has also been a long-standing demand of activists and experts to make Mumbai’s suburban train network a separate administrative unit that functions differently from the rest of Indian Railways.
“There should be a separate administrative office for Mumbai suburban and fares should be determined scientifically after considering various costs,” said Rishi Agarwal, a transport expert.
Currently, the suburban network includes a central line (CST to Karjat-Khopoli and Kasara), western line (Churchgate to Virar and further Dahanu), harbour line (CST to Panvel-Andheri) and trans-harbour line (Thane-Vashi and Panvel).

Jul 24 2016 (08:47)
DhnEcr~   4067 blog posts
Re# 1939889-1            Tags   Past Edits
Get rid of Mst Qst discount of 75-80% instead offer max of 10-20% as Metro offers in Delhi or Kolkata

Jul 24 2016 (09:37)
uks1955~   1109 blog posts   3 correct pred (50% accurate)
Re# 1939889-2            Tags   Past Edits
लोकल ट्रेन चलाने से रेल को जो घाटा होता है उसका एक उपाय यह किया जा सकता है कि चेन्नई ,कोलकाता ,मुंबई दिल्ली की लोकल रेलों के नेटवर्क को उपनगरीय रेल के तौर पर अलग कर दिया जाय और इनके किराए में पचास प्रतिशतकी वृद्धि की जाय।

Jul 24 2016 (21:42)
For Better Managed Indian Railways~   1859 blog posts
Re# 1939889-3            Tags   Past Edits
Woh bhi kam sabit hoga, ghata poora karne ke liye aur jyada badhotri karni hogi. Passenger trains bhi isee category mein hi aati hai aur unmebhi Monthly pass banta hai.
IRly has planned to convert all passenger trains into memu/ dmu trains like suburban trains, so practically there will be no difference between suburban trains passenger trains on rest of India. Issue is not the suburban trains or passenger trains, issue is excessive concession given on monthly passes of both in addition to very low ordinary second class fares.

ARP (Advanced Reservation Period) Calculator

Reservations Open Today @ 8am for:
Trains with ARP 10 Dep on: Mon Jan 30
Trains with ARP 15 Dep on: Sat Feb 4
Trains with ARP 30 Dep on: Sun Feb 19
Trains with ARP 120 Dep on: Sat May 20


Rail News

New Trains

Site Announcements

  • Entry# 2133126
    Today (01:29AM)

    The modification to the TL Update scheme - i.e. the introduction of the new RAC System - has led to some efficiency with TL Updates. More TLs are being discussed, and quickly moved up. However, we still have on Average, about 300 Waitlisted TLs in the backlog at any time, and our hard-working and diligent TLMs...
  • Entry# 2126247
    Jan 13 (11:57PM)

    Here are some guidelines for members regarding the new Report button and the revamped FM system: 1. If you have ANY complaint about a blog or ANY other issues, please USE the Report button and file a Complaint. Most complaints are resolved by FMs within seconds/minutes. (Some require further discussion). FMs have...
  • Entry# 2125399
    Jan 13 (08:58AM)

    Often we have some TL Entries seemingly in WaitList forever. Usually, the reason for this is that TLMs have already looked at the TL Entry but are not confident enough to Confirm it or are looking for more inputs from the Member regarding the source, etc. And this delay eventually causes...
  • Entry# 2122843
    Jan 10 (10:15PM)

    This is to address persistent and lingering questions about FM Appointments: . 1. Being an FM is a service. It is NOT supposed to be some kind of "reward" or "medal" to "deserving" members. The ULTIMATE OBJECTIVE of the process is to promptly handle/look into Reports filed by members, which is expected to...
  • Entry# 2115377
    Jan 04 (12:30AM)

    There are some changes to the Forum section. . The Objection feature is now completely GONE. We now only have a "Report Abuse" button. When the Report button is used, an alert is sent to the "Forum Monitor" group. ALL FMs will see an "FM Alert" notification at the top. Thereafter, they will...
  • Entry# 2095722
    Dec 18 2016 (11:34PM)

    Very soon, we shall have a points-system for Timeline updates, Atlas updates, News updates, Blog Tagging, News Tagging, Blog Tagging, etc. The reason for this is that some kinds of updates require more hard work and are more useful than others. Up-to-date News about late-running trains, updating TTs of trains only...
Scroll to Top
Scroll to Bottom

Go to Mobile site