Travel Tip
 Conf TL
 RF Club
 FM Alert
 FM Approval
Forum Super Search
Freq Contact:
Posting Date From:
Posting Date To:
Blog Category:
Train Type:
ONLY with Pic/Vid:
Sort by: Date:     Word Count:     Popularity:     
Public:    Pvt: Monitor:    RailFan Club:    

Full Site Search
  Full Site Search  
Sat Sep 22 18:40:21 IST
PostPost Trn TipPost Stn TipAdvanced Search

Blog Entry# 2982555
Posted: Jan 08 (22:14)

1 Responses
Last Response: Jan 08 (22:14)
Rail News
Other News
Jan 08 (16:00)   `Railways went ahead with a failed bio-toilet model`

Jayashree ❖ Amita*^   41052 news posts
Entry# 2982555   News Entry# 326484         Tags   Past Edits
For 24 years, the Indian Railways have tried to find a solution to the 3,980 tonnes–497 truck-loads (at 8 tonnes per truck)–of excreta ejected from trains on to tracks every day. The latest effort was the installation of what are called "bio digesters" beneath train toilet seats where bacteria in a compost chamber digest excreta.
But the bio-toilets are no better than "septic tanks" and the water they led out no better than "raw sewage", IndiaSpend reported on November 23, 2017, citing a study by the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Madras. The government's auditor, the Comptroller and Auditor General, also pointed to many flaws in these toilets, as IndiaSpend reported on January 6, 2018.
IIT Madras study was not the first time the bio-toilets in Indian trains, fitted for Rs 1,305 crore, were criticised. A 2007 study, jointly conducted by the Lucknow-based Research Designs and Standards Organisation (RDSO) and IIT Kanpur, also concluded that excreta wasn't being treated in the bio-digesters. The railways has not made this report public.
IIT professor Vinod Tare, 61, who headed this study, is currently a professor of environmental engineering at IIT Kanpur. Between 2004 and 2006, he was the project investigator for the Indian Railways scheme to develop "environment friendly toilets".
Tare's area of interest is natural resource conservation and regeneration. He currently heads the government think tank, Centre for Ganga River Basin Management and Studies (C-Ganga), and advises the Namami Gange, the government's flagship programme for the conservation of the Ganga.
Vinod Tare, 61, who headed the study on bio digesters, is currently a professor of environmental engineering at IIT Kanpur. Between 2004 and 2006, he was the project investigator for the Indian Railways scheme to develop "environment friendly toilets".
In this interview, Tare explained the problems of waste management in Indian trains and the reasons why it fails.
After 24 years of experimentation, the Indian scientific community has been unable to develop a workable model on rail bio-toilets. Now there are new plans to fit vacuum toilets atop the bio-toilets. In the meanwhile, costs have spiraled. How do you analyse the situation?
Challenges in the Indian context are many. For one, Indians are in the habit of "wet cleaning" (in toilets) unlike the "dry cleaning" practices in Western countries. Therefore, the volume of waste in Indian trains is substantially more. Also, train coaches in India–with an average of 72 berths–carry a bigger load and passengers are taken to longer distances, as compared to the rest of the world. Temperature variations in Indian trains vary from a high of 45°C (degrees Celcius) to as low as 4°C.
This having been said, there is little doubt that the approach of the Indian rail establishment has been extremely awkward. An experts committee headed by me had–in 2007–concluded that bio-toilets developed by the Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) were not workable. Yet, the Indian Railways went ahead with the decision to proliferate this model. These toilets failed in the 2013 Kumbh Mela (the periodic congregation of Hindus on the banks of the Ganga to mark a solar eclipse) at Allahabad.
Later, the army people told me at a seminar that the toilets installed at the Siachen glacier were non-functional. All kinds of issues are now emerging with the rail bio-toilets, which are no better than septic tanks. IIT Madras, in a recent study, has come up with similar findings. Problems are unlikely to get solved by fitting vacuum toilets atop the bio-toilets. Evacuation systems will still be needed to be installed at yards.
Technological solutions exist, but the intention to find a lasting solution is not there. Different sets of bureaucrats have only been interested in fulfilling targets and in ensuring that their tenures get completed in a trouble-free manner. This is the reason that the scheme is in such a mess.
In response to the IndiaSpend article, the Indian Railways have claimed that the rail bio-toilets were different from and probably more efficient than the DRDO stationary toilets. Can you explain?
This cannot be. Indeed, the situation is quite the contrary. The retention time of faecal matter in a train toilet is much less, as compared to stationary toilets. The bio-degradation process is required to get completed while the train is in motion and travelling across different climatic zones. This is a big challenge.
In any case, there is no difference in design or technology of a stationary or a train toilet. See, this is the problem. Instead of working towards lasting solutions, the establishment has continued to justify its actions.
What exactly are the problems with the DRDO's toilets?
These toilets are no better than holding tanks. Very little biological treatment is happening. Claims that human excreta is broken up into gases (methane) and liquid by using a compound of bacterium obtained from Antarctica are not based on scientific data.
If, according to claims, methane is being produced, this is a problem–as methane is hazardous and inflammable material. If methane is not getting produced, it means that no biological treatment is happening in the toilet tanks, in any case. Both ways it is a problem.
Substantial spending has–and continues to be done–on installation of bio-toilets. But, my view is that on-board treatment of human excreta is difficult. Evacuation facilities and treatment plants–for compost or biogas–can be set up in the rail yards. As head of the bio-toilet committee of the Technology Mission of Railway Safety, I had suggested this in 2009. I also discussed the idea at a meeting with then railways minister Suresh Prabhu in 2015.
Series concluded. You can read the first part here and our November 2017 report on railway bio-toilets here.

1 Public Posts - Mon Jan 08, 2018

ARP (Advanced Reservation Period) Calculator

Reservations Open Today @ 8am for:
Trains with ARP 10 Dep on: Tue Oct 2
Trains with ARP 15 Dep on: Sun Oct 7
Trains with ARP 30 Dep on: Mon Oct 22
Trains with ARP 120 Dep on: Sun Jan 20


Rail News

  • आज से आरा स्टेशन पर ठहरेगी कुंभ एक्सप्रेस
    News Entry# 359774
    by: Anupam Enosh Sarkar*^~  Today (18:26)

    जागरण संवाददाता, कोलकाता : 22 सितंबर से 12369-12370 अप और डाउन कुंभ एक्सप्रेस आरा स्टेशन पर ठहरेगी। अगले छह माह तक प्रायोगिक तौर पर ट्रेन के उक्त स्टेशन पर ठहराव को मंजूरी दी गई है। ट्रेन आरा स्टेशन पर दो मिनट के लिए रुकेगी। हावड़ा से खुलने के पश्चात हावड़ा-हरिद्वार कुंभ...
  • स्टेशन की व्यवस्थाएं 'ट्रैक' पर आने की उम्मीद
    News Entry# 359773
    by: Anupam Enosh Sarkar*^~  Today (18:19)

    संवाद सहयोगी झींझक: कंचौसी में मुख्यमंत्री का कार्यक्रम होने से लोगों में रेलवे स्टेशन की दशा सुधरने की आस जागी है। कानपुर देहात व औरैया जनपद की सीमा में स्थित कंचौसी रेलवे स्टेशन की आय सालाना करीब 36 लाख है। यहां से रोजाना करीब 6 सौ मासिक टिकट धारी यात्री...
  • तीन दिन से खड़ी मालगाड़ी ने बढ़ाई दिक्कत
    News Entry# 359772
    by: Anupam Enosh Sarkar*^~  Today (18:17)

    जागरण संवाददाता, ज्ञानपुर (भदोही) : पूर्वाेत्तर रेलवे के मंडुआडीह - इलाहाबाद रेल खंड पर स्थित जंगीगंज रेलवे स्टेशन के प्लेटफार्म संख्या दो पर तीन दिनों से खड़ी डाउन मऊ मालगाड़ी के चलते यात्रियों की दिक्कत बढ़ गई है। मालगाड़ी के खड़ी हो जाने से जहां यात्रियों समेत स्कूली बच्चों को यात्रियों...
  • यात्रीगण कृपया ध्यान दें, यहां रहेगा पांच घंटे का ब्लॉक; ये ट्रेनें होंगी प्रभावित
    News Entry# 359771
    by: Anupam Enosh Sarkar*^~  Today (18:15)

    देहरादून, [जेएनएन]: 23 सितंबर को देहरादून-हर्रावाला रेलवे ट्रैक के बीच पांच घंटे का ब्लॉक रहेगा। इस दौरान दून रेलवे स्टेशन पर आने-जाने वाली ट्रेनें पूरी तरह से प्रभावित रहेंगी। अमृतसर एक्सप्रेस (अमृतसर-देहरादून) का संचालन हरिद्वार तक ही हो सकेगा। वहीं, बांद्रा, लिंक, शताब्दी एक्सप्रेस भी घंटों देरी से पहुंचेगी और रवाना...
  • दिल्‍ली-मेरठ रैपिड रेल ट्रैक और मेट्रो स्टेशन के काम में आएगी तेजी
    News Entry# 359770
    by: Anupam Enosh Sarkar*^~  Today (18:13)

    मेरठ (जेएनएन)। दिल्ली-मेरठ रैपिड रेल प्रोजेक्ट का लगभग 25 किलोमीटर का हिस्सा मेरठ से ही गति पकड़ेगा। इसके लिए मेरठ में इंजीनियर तैनात कर प्रोजेक्ट की मॉनिटरिंग होगी। इसके लिए साकेत में कार्यालय खोला जा चुका है। बस अब प्रोजेक्ट के पीआइबी में फाइनल होने के बाद कैबिनेट की बैठक में...

New Trains

Site Announcements

  • Entry# 3710716
    Aug 14 2018 (11:04AM)

    This is regarding the appointment of Monitors. For TLMs, we require a minimum of 1000 Confirmed TLs. For FMs, we require members to promise to abide by the guidelines and be free of controversies. For other Monitors, we require the member to be in good standing. . However, "eligibility" does NOT always mean...
  • Entry# 3645007
    Jul 20 2018 (03:28PM)

    This is an advance notice of an upcoming change: 1. We shall be removing the Login/Forum section from the RailCal app as it is cumbersome, buggy and lacking in features. . 2. We shall soon be introducing a dedicated app called "Rail Messenger" for both Android and iOS, for all blogging/messaging purposes. The app...
  • Entry# 3644431
    Jul 20 2018 (12:42PM)

    The following changes are being made: 1. To restore the fun back to PNR Predictions, PNR Predictions will NOT be hidden anymore. PNR Predictions by members can be seen by ALL, before and after Charting. New members often look towards our expert predictors for hints, and we are reinstanting that. . 2. To better...
  • Entry# 3601043
    Jul 04 2018 (12:36PM)

    @all: While we do nominally allow multiple IDs, these multiple IDs are NOT allowed to engage in misuse and "mischief". Voting multiple times in the same poll using multiple IDs, rating each other IDs' blogs using multiple IDs, etc. are classified as "gross misuse". . This is an advance notice that some of the...
  • Entry# 3555168
    Jun 20 2018 (10:33PM)

    @all: IRI is a PUBLIC information website, like Wikipedia. The voluntarily posted Blogs, Train/Station Tips, Train/Station Pics, Polls, Train TTs, PNRs, etc. comprise the permanent publicly viewable and searchable repository of IRI. A PUBLIC info website is unlike WhatsApp, FaceBook, Instagram, etc. where people post personal pics and other stuff, which CAN...
  • Entry# 3535285
    Jun 15 2018 (08:28PM)

    This is a clarification to all members regarding our Forum Guidelines and the FM Group. SWs are issued for very clear cases of abuse and misbehaviour by a member. . At this time, we have had many members against whom SW is issued claim that: "I am a long-time member of IRI, and have...
Scroll to Top
Scroll to Bottom
Go to Mobile site
Important Note: This website NEVER solicits for Money or Donations. Please beware of anyone requesting/demanding money on behalf of IRI. Thanks.
Disclaimer: This website has NO affiliation with the Government-run site of Indian Railways. This site does NOT claim 100% accuracy of fast-changing Rail Information. YOU are responsible for independently confirming the validity of information through other sources.
India Rail Info Privacy Policy