Travel Tip
 Conf TL
 RF Club
 FM Alert
Forum Super Search
Posting Date From:
Posting Date To:
Train Type:
ONLY with Pic/Vid:
Sort by: Date:     Word Count:     Popularity:     
Public:    Pvt: Monitor:    RailFan Club:    

Full Site Search
  Full Site Search  
Mon Apr 23, 2018 09:44:12 ISTHomeTrainsΣChainsAtlasPNRForumGalleryNewsFAQTripsLoginFeedback
PostPost Trn TipPost Stn TipAdvanced Search

Blog Entry# 3203731
Posted: Mar 14 2018 (20:44)

6 Responses
Last Response: Mar 15 2018 (16:05)
Rail News
IR Affairs
Mar 14 2018 (20:17)   Should we as Indians pay more for rail travel? CAG says so in spite of profitable freight business

a2z~   355 news posts
Entry# 3203731   News Entry# 331397         Tags   Past Edits
The Comptroller and Auditor General of India has come out with a report on the revenue and expense of the Indian Railways. The CAG tabled this report with the Parliament, and highlighted that the Railways should revise their fares. The report says the Railways incurred a whopping Rs 36286.33 crore loss​, with most of the losses being attributed to heavily subsidised passenger fares in the period 2015-16. "The Railways Ministry needs to revisit the passenger and other coaching tariffs so as to recover the cost of operations in a phased manner and reduce its losses in its core activities," the report said.
According to the CAG report, the overall revenue increased by 4.57%, but it remained lower than the CAGR (Compounded Annual
Growth Rate) of nearly 15% recorded during 2011-15. The CAG came down heavily on the Railways for setting improper fares. The report said, "The fixation of passenger fare and freight charges should be based on the cost involved so that it brings both rationality and flexibility in pricing considering the financial health of the railways and the current market scenario."
The report conceded that there is no "justification for not fully recovering the cost of passenger services in case of AC 1st Class, First Class and AC 2-Tier". In case you are among those crores commuting on concessional fares, the CAG has called for scaling them down. "Since one of the factors for non- recovery of full cost from these classes could be issue of free and concessional fare passes/tickets to various beneficiaries in good numbers, this practice needs to be scaled down," the report said.
Yes people often travel dangerously. Not because the tickets are expensive, but for want of space inside overflowing coaches. Should Railways still look at Profits? Operating Ratio: The CAG found that the operating ratio was higher and meant lower earnings for the Railways. The operating ratio is a margin of expenses to the earnings. From a ratio of 90.49 in 2015-16, the margin has come down to 96.50 in 2016-17. "The railways incurred excess expenditure of Rs 33.13 crore during the year 2016-17. The excess expenditure does not augur well for fiscal prudence besides undermining parliamentary control," CAG said.
Surprisingly though, the freight services arm of the Indian Railways made a profit. of Rs 42,426.63 crore during 2015-16. The report says that 85.53% of the profit from freight traffic was utilised to compensate the loss on operation of passenger and other coaching services. This is not the first time that the Railways have been blamed of their social service orientation. Cheaper fares may be the hope for nearly crores of Indians to commute distant places. But, it has always remained as a drag on the sheets of Railways. The Niti Aayog, the government's think tank too had similar thoughts.
This is the number of train ticket buyers in Mumbai alone. But still no profits? Impact of Social Obligations A report on the website of Niti Aayog suggests that "social service" orientation of the Railways impacted its revenue. "The underlying reasons often cited for such losses by IR include charging fares well below IR’s costs across all classes (possible exception being AC 3 class), granting a range of concessions to various categories of passengers (senior citizens, war widows, students, national sports awardees etc.), continued operations of uneconomic branch lines etc. IR also incurs some loss in the form of revenue foregone for its goods (freight transport) business. The Explanatory Memorandum to the Railway Budget generally includes a statement of revenue foregone due to concessional freight tariffs for certain commodities. However, at an overall business level, the goods business makes profits and ultimately ends up cross-subsidizing losses of passenger business," reads the report.
The Niti Aayog's report cites the social service orientation by quoting former Prime Minister Lal Bahadur Shastri. Shastri while delivering the Budget speech for 1955-56 said, "We have been following in recent years a liberal policy .of giving concessions, particularly in connection with travel for educational purposes and other nation building activities. The financial effect of these concessions is partially reflected in the fact that the average amount earned per passenger during 1953-54 has decreased from 5.22 pies to 5.17 pies per mile." The report finds the following service obligations as a drag on the Railways revenue:
Non-Suburban Passenger Services: Concessions to various categories of passengers. Categories of passengers given concessions in fares are Senior citizens, Students, Recipients of gallantry awards, National Sports awards, Participants of National and State sports tournaments, Shram awardees, War widows, Patients suffering from cancer, TB, other serious diseases, Handicapped persons, Press correspondents, etc Sub-urban Passenger Services: Fares of various classes of tickets lower than system costs, and season ticket concessions to suburban passengers. Goods Services: Carriage of essential commodities at concessional rates. Concessions to Postal traffic, military traffic, registered newspapers & magazines, North East etc. Uneconomic Branch lines: Continued operations of uneconomic branch lines.
The 7th pay commission and social burden led to the operating margin declining to a lowest in 16 years in 2015. Suresh Prabhu, the former minister for Railways, was pressed to find out alternative measures to improve revenues of the railways. The ministry in 2015, sought the assistance of National Institute of Public Finance and Policy and the Niti Aayog to envision revenue-generating areas. The Niti Aayog reported that the Indian Railways, based on its 2014-15 balance sheet, expends Rs 1.67 for every Rupee earned in passenger business.
​Loss for running ​s​econd-​c​lass services ​stands at Rs 11094 crores, and the Railway board suggests not to consider sundry revenues and expenses
What does it imply? The Niti Aayog from its report called for a revision of fares for various classes. It compared the fares of Railways with that of other travel routes. Thankfully it kept airlines as a mode of travelling out of its computation. But it compared tariff levels with AC bus services to arrive at a comparable fare rate. Information from domains like makemytrip.com, and RedBus.in were used to compute indicative fares of the Indian Railways
The Niti Aayog believes that using these rates would help the Railways recover 60% of under-recoveries in Sleeper Class / Non-Ac, and nearly 99% in 2nd Class or Ordinary class. The Aayog in its footnote calls the report as an "indicative commentary". The Aayog's recent report on the Railways is on accounting reforms. It says nothing on tariffs and fares. Would it be wise to assume that the Aayog is taking time to study on the implications of its study, especially with elections close on heels. It will be wiser to ignore the political context. But from a macroeconomic perspective, 2018 has already seen major ill- rising petrol costs, escalating provisioning for bad loans and NPAs (Non performing Assets), Scams- Nirav Modi, Rotomac etc, and concerns on 7th Pay Commission. With most PSUs bleeding in the red, a liquidity crunch in the market, the government may be forced to plug leakages- majorly subsidies. And this could likely impact your travel costs on the Indian Railways.

1 posts - Wed Mar 14, 2018

Mar 15 2018 (14:03)
a2z~   2941 blog posts
Re# 3203731-2            Tags   Past Edits
Mr Prabhu took keen interest in adoption of the "double entry" accounting system prevalent in corporates and it was implemented in Ajmer division as a pilot project. After his departure from Rly Ministry, not much has been heard about it. Sine new RM is also a Chartered Accountant, it is expected he too shall take keen interest and pursue this matter.

Mar 15 2018 (14:11)
Kishor*^~   4811 blog posts   124 correct pred (63% accurate)
Re# 3203731-3            Tags   Past Edits
This is heartening news.
But Govt Babus and Govt machinery is such that good things fail quickly.
If that was successful in one division, then same must be known to Chairman Railway board and new incumbent as well.
But attitude of 'who cares' is failing the change.
am having no sources to verify this as on date

Mar 15 2018 (14:30)
DhnEcr~   6354 blog posts
Re# 3203731-4            Tags   Past Edits
The image speaks volumes on the need to increase AC 3A coaches at the expense of 2A and 1A. Any SF with at max 2 2A coaches and atleast 5-7 3A coaches. Sleeper should also be decreased as it is 2nd most loss making.

Mar 15 2018 (15:55)
knkprasad956*^~   2422 blog posts
Re# 3203731-5            Tags   Past Edits
Thanks for updates

Mar 15 2018 (16:05)
venki~   1361 blog posts
Re# 3203731-6            Tags   Past Edits
As usual except 3A all classes are in losses. Good to see 3A profit almost doubled 13-14 to 14-15.
Lets wait for this GOVT stats

ARP (Advanced Reservation Period) Calculator

Reservations Open Today @ 8am for:
Trains with ARP 10 Dep on: Thu May 3
Trains with ARP 15 Dep on: Tue May 8
Trains with ARP 30 Dep on: Wed May 23
Trains with ARP 120 Dep on: Tue Aug 21


Rail News

  • सप्तक्रांति में सवार होने के लिए मारामारी
    News Entry# 334918
    by: Indian Railways the life line of our Nation~  Today (08:56)

    आनंद विहार जाने वाली अप सप्तक्रांति सुपर फास्ट एक्सप्रेस में सवार होने के लिए रविवार को जंक्शन पर यात्रियों में मारामारी की स्थिति रही। दोपहर 12 बजे ट्रेन के प्लेटफॉर्म नंबर-3 पर लगते ही जनरल बोगियों में सवार होने के लिए यात्रियों में होड़ मच गई। बोगियों का दरवाजा खुलने में...
  • ‘साफ्ट टारगेट’ बने रेल इंजन
    News Entry# 334917
    by: Aaditya^~  Today (07:12)

    जासं, वाराणसी : कैंट रेलवे स्टेशन पर आतंकी घटना होने के बाद भी रेल प्रशासन गंभीर नहीं है। स्टेशन परिसर में न तो मुकम्मल तौर पर जांच होती है और न सुरक्षा उपकरण ही दुरुस्त है। साथ ही रेल कर्मियों की लापरवाही इस कदर कि वे रेल इंजनों को भी सुरक्षित...
  • एक तो ट्रेन विलंबित दूसरे अभ्यर्थियों का हंगामा
    News Entry# 334916
    by: Aaditya^~  Today (07:10)

    जासं, वाराणसी : कैंट स्टेशन पर इन दिनों यात्रियों को परेशानी का सामना करना पड़ रहा है। एक तो ट्रेनें लेट चल रही हैं तो दूसरे सेना भर्ती समेत नगर में संचालित परीक्षाओं के अभ्यर्थियों का हंगामा हो रहा है। रविवार को भी कई ट्रेनें लेट थी तो वहीं यात्रियों को...
  • रेल इंजन निर्माण में अगुआ बना डीरेका
    News Entry# 334915
    by: Aaditya^~  Today (07:09)

    स्थापना दिवस आज
    जासं, वाराणसी : डीजल रेल इंजन कारखाना का शिलान्यास 23 अप्रैल, 1956 को देश के प्रथम राष्ट्रपति डा. राजेंद्र...
  • हंसिए मत.., मजबूरी समङिाए
    News Entry# 334914
    by: Aaditya^~  Today (07:07)

    गर्मी से बेहाल यात्री ने पांच सौ रुपये के मिनरल वाटर से प्लेटफार्म पर किया खुलेआम स्नान
    Click here to enlarge image...

New Trains

Site Announcements

  • Entry# 2547009
    Oct 16 2017 (10:21PM)

    As per the recent post , the new Pax Login feature has now been introduced. Here are the details of the feature set. . 1. Now you may login to the site as a Member or a Passenger, or BOTH Member & Passenger at the same time. Passenger login is called "Pax Login"...
  • Entry# 2517609
    Oct 11 2017 (09:33AM)

    As detailed here , last month, some changes were made to the PNR section. In the next phase of this rollout, we shall be further separating "Passengers" from "Members". . 1. "Passengers" will be able to login using ONLY their PNRs (no password). We shall have a Pax Login above the current...
  • Entry# 2418661
    Sep 25 2017 (07:09AM)

    @all: There are some changes coming to the PNR Forum. 1. All PNRs will be anonymized, i.e. you won't see who posted the PNRs or search PNRs by Traveller. This is to better protect the confidentiality of travelling members and their travel plans. However, members will still be able to search their OWN...
  • Entry# 2409730
    Sep 15 2017 (11:46PM)

    In recent times, the number of FM Complaints regarding "targeting me", "offensive content", "sarcastic comment", "bashing", etc. have been increasing. This has led to increased censorship and throttling of open discussions. . This is a clarification that this site is meant for a FREE EXCHANGE of ideas. Some arguments/debates/disagreements/jokes/sarcasm are ALLOWED and are...
  • Entry# 2390218
    Aug 25 2017 (12:59PM)

    There has been a partial rollout of a modification to Timeline entries. The implementation will be complete within a week. 1. Void & RAC buttons have been removed. . 2. TL Entries can now be Edited and Fixed by the original updater, if there are errors. So there is no need to Void TLs...
  • Entry# 2175399
    Feb 23 2017 (01:22PM)

    There has recently been a lot of frustration among RFs when their Station Pics, Loco Pics, Train Pics get rejected because the "number is not showing", "shed is not visible", the loco/train is at a distance, Train Board is too small, "better pic available", etc. . To address this issue, effective tomorrow, ALL...
Scroll to Top
Scroll to Bottom
Go to Mobile site
Disclaimer: This website has NO affiliation with the Government-run site of Indian Railways. This site does NOT claim 100% accuracy of fast-changing Rail Information. YOU are responsible for independently confirming the validity of information through other sources.