ok. now just tell me what should be the criteria for a successful train ? do you mean to say that all trains that the IR runs should always be full all the year round ? is it possible ? than maybe just a couple of trains might run and that too between metro cities. do not be a fool and keep harping about losses. think of the facility for travelling public. if you check their is no daily connectivity from Hapa / Rajkot / Ahmedabad to South India. we can get trains daily from BRC and BSR but those are all coming from North and therefore, very difficult to get seats.